The Center for the Study of Ethics in Society at Western Michigan University participates in two different undergraduate ethics competitions: the Association for Practical and Professional Ethics Intercollegiate Ethics Bowl and Bioethics Bowl.
Intercollegiate Ethics Bowl
The APPE Intercollegiate Ethics Bowl provides students with an opportunity to practice applying the moral theories and argumentation principles that they learn in their ethics classes. Students receive a set of case studies in advance involving ethical issues in a number of practical contexts, including engineering, law, medicine, personal relationships, school and politics.
During a round, each team takes turns presenting its position on a case and critiquing the other team’s position on a different case. Teams must answer questions about their positions from a panel of judges. Judges assign scores based on logical consistency, clarity, focus and thoroughness.
WMU has competed in the bowl contest every year since it expanded from an intramural event at the Illinois Institute of Technology to a small regional contest involving a handful of colleges in 1994—an event WMU won. The competition went national in 1997. The national championship takes place every spring at the annual meeting of the Association for Practical and Professional Ethics. WMU’s best national showings were third out of 14 teams in 1998, fifth out of 26 teams in 2000, and ninth out of 32 teams in 2007.
The bowl became a tiered competition beginning in 2007, with practices and regional contests taking place every fall. WMU’s team won the 2006 regional qualifier at Harper College and the 2007 qualifier at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
2018 Ethics Bowl team
There were 30 teams at the Upper Midwest regional qualifier at Illinois Institute of Technology on Nov. 17 representing 20 schools. The top four schools (with 4-0-0 records) qualified for nationals outright (U-Madison, Grand Valley, Millikin and Illinois Wesleyan). If the region gets a fifth bid, Adrian, with a 3-0-1 record, will also advance. Western was among four teams that finished with a 3-1-0 record, ranking 9th overall based on win-loss record and total points awarded by the judges.
Students representing Western Michigan University were, from left: Anna Costa, a senior majoring in environmental and sustainability studies and communication studies; Ben Ulrich, a senior majoring in philosophy and biology; Evan "EV" Vecziedins, a freshman majoring in aviation flight science; and Michael Van Sickle, a senior majoring in biomedical science. The team's assistant coaches were Chad Watson, Anna Kietzerow and Luke Golemon, all master's students in philosophy. The Ethics Center director, Sandra Borden, was head coach and faculty sponsor of the team.
The Bioethics Bowl uses a similar format to the Intercollegiate Ethics Bowl. It is a national competition that takes place every spring at the National Undergraduate Bioethics Conference and focuses on a narrower range of ethical issues in science, medicine and public health. Practices and competition take place every spring semester.
Join a team
If you are interested in being on one of these teams, contact Sandra Borden.