Generational
Equity, Generational Interdependence, and the Framing of the Debate
Over Social Security Reform
John B. Williamson, Tay K. McNamara, & Stephanie A. Howling
This article analyzes the differences between the generational equity
and generational interdependence conceptual packages used to frame arguments
in the debate over policies such as Social Security reform. It begins
with a history of the generational equity debate. This is followed by
an analysis of the assumptions, values, and beliefs that inform each
of these two ideological frames. It presents an analysis of why the
generational equity frame has dominated the debate and highlights some
of the limitations of this perspective.
The Culture
of Race, Class, and Poverty: The Emergence of a Cultural Discourse in
Early Cold War Social Work (1946-1963)
Laura Curran
Through a primary source historical analysis, this article discusses
the emergence of a cultural discourse in the early cold war (1946-1963)
social work literature. It traces the evolution of social work's cultural
narrative in relation to social scientific perspectives, changing race
relations, and increasing welfare caseloads. Social work scholars originally
employed their cultural discourse to account for racial and ethnic difference
and eventually came to examine class and poverty from this viewpoint
as well. This cultural framework wrestled with internal contradictions.
It simultaneously celebrated and problematized cultural difference and
foreshadowed both latter twentieth century multiculturalism as well
as neo-conservative thought.
The Lived
Experience of Welfare Reform in Drug-UsingWelfare-Needy Households in
Inner-City New York
Eloise Dunlap, Andrew Golub, & Bruce D. Johnson
Welfare reform has transformed a needs-based family income support into
temporary assistance for persons entering the workforce. This paper
uses observations from an ethnographic study covering the period from
1995- 2001 to examine the impact on drug-using welfare-needy households
in inner-city New York. The analysis suggests that studies may underestimate
the extent to which substance use is associated with welfare problems.
Nearly all of these already distressed households lost their AFDC/TANF
benefits, had difficulty with work programs, and were having more difficulty
covering expenses. The conclusion highlights ways to better study this
population and policy initiatives that could help them reform their
impoverished lives for themselves and their children.
Serving the
"Hard-to-Serve": The Use of Clinical Knowledge in Welfare Reform
Rufina Lee & Laura Curran
This critical analysis of recent research and evaluations of welfare
reform efforts describes how states have increasingly drawn on clinical
knowledge in their efforts to move "hard-to-serve" recipients into the
labor force. It argues that a clinical perspective is helpful as it
brings attention to the mental health needs of low-income women. At
the same time, however, this article suggests that states' use of a
clinical framework is problematic in so far as it based on limited knowledge,
dampens a broad discussion of the relationship between poverty and mental
health, contributes to policy ambiguity, and increases recipient oversight.
Prevalence
of Child Welfare Services Involvement among Homeless and Low-Income
Mothers: A Five-year Birth Cohort Study
Jennifer F. Culhane, David Webb, Susan Grim, Stephen Metraux, &
Dennis Culhane
This paper investigates the five-year prevalence of child welfare services
involvement and foster care placement among a population-based cohort
of births in a large US city, by housing status of the mothers (mothers
who have been homeless at least once, other low-income neighborhood
residents, and all others), and by number of children. Children of mothers
with at least one homeless episode have the greatest rate of involvement
with child welfare services (37%), followed by other low-income residents
(9.2%), and all others (4.0%). Involvement rates increase with number
of children for all housing categories, with rates highest among women
with four or more births (33%), particularly for those mothers who have
been homeless at least once (54%). Among families involved with child
welfare services, the rate of placement in foster care is highest for
the index children of women with at least one episode of homelessness
(62%), followed by other low-income mothers (39%) and all others (39%).
Half of the birth cohort eventually involved with child welfare services
was among the group of women who have ever used the shelter system,
as were 60% of the cohort placed in foster care. Multivariate logistic
regression analyses reveal that mothers with one or more homeless episodes
and mothers living in low-income neighborhoods have significantly greater
risk of child welfare service involvement (OR = 5.67 and OR = 1.51,
respectively) and foster care placement (OR = 8.82 andOR= 1.59 , respectively).
The implications for further research, and for child welfare risk assessment
and prevention are discussed. Specifically, the salience of housing
instability/homelessness to risk of child welfare service involvement
is highlighted.
Spousal Abuse:
Vietnamese Children's Reports of Parental Violence
Yoko Baba & Susan B. Murray
This exploratory study used mailed questionnaires completed by 131 Vietnamese
students to examine domestic violence patterns in parents' marital relationships.
Research objectives included: (1) gaining an understanding of spousal
abuse among Vietnamese couples; and (2) assessing which variables (demographic
characteristics, decision-making power, and cultural adaptation, beliefs
in traditional gender roles, and conflicts in the family) are correlated
with spousal abuse. Findings suggest that although both parents used
reasoning, mental abuse and physical abuse in their marital relationships,
Vietnamese fathers were more likely to be physically abusive than mothers.
Additional variables associated with family conflicts are also examined.
Research implications and suggestions for further research are discussed.
The Social
Problem of Depression: A Multi-theoretical Analysis
Rich Furman Kimberly Bender
The purpose of this paper is to discuss the social problem of depression
from a multi-theoretical perspective. It explores depression through
the lens of two psychologically based theories of human behavior, existential
theory and cognitive theory, as well as through the vehicle of two sociological
theories, Marxist theory and the theory of oppression. By understanding
how each of these theories explains depression, social workers may be
helped to see the complexity of treating the problem. It is the belief
of the authors that social work literature, which is often dominated
by reductionist, quantitatively based research studies, has increasingly
ignored theoretical explorations of key social problems such as depression,
to the determent of the profession and the disciplines which inform
it.
Indicators
for Safe Family Reunification: How Professionals Differ
Brad R. Karoll & John Poertner
Many professionals who work with substance-affected families consider
the time limits prescribed by the Adoption and Safe Families Act (1997)
to be unrealistically short. The high prevalence of substance use in
child welfare cases requires professionals to quickly determine when
it is safe to reunify children placed because of abuse or neglect in
concert with this serious family problem. This exploratory study identified
similarities and differences on different indicators of safe reunification
between judges who hear juvenile cases, private agency child welfare
caseworkers, and substance abuse counselors. The study examined these
professionals' rating of the importance of each indicator. Judges, caseworkers,
and counselors from a large midwestern state were surveyed. All groups
agreed on the importance of 15 of the 19 identified areas of functioning.
Judges and substance abuse counselors significantly differed on four
factors; counselors and caseworkers differed on two. Implications of
the findings for practice are discussed.
Book Reviews
Emotionally Involved:
The Impact of Researching Rape.
Rebecca Campbell
Reviewed by Laura S. Abrams
Sociology of
Religion: Contemporary Developments
Kevin J. Christiano, William H. Swatos Jr., & Peter Kivisto
Reviewed by Ram A. Cnaan
The Assault on Social Policy
William Roth
Reviewed by
Larry Nackerud
The Making of the Chinese Industrial Workplace: State, Revolution and
Labor Management
Mark W. Frazier
Reviewed by M. K. Lee
Tramps, Unfit Mothers and Neglected Children: Negotiating the Family
in Late Nineteenth Century Philadelphia
Sherri Broder
Reviewd by Leslie Leighninger
Colored White: Transcending the Racial past
David R. Roediger
Reviewed by Kurt C. Organista
Book Notes
Drug Courts
in Theory and Practice
James L. Nolan Jr.
Fatherhood Arrested:
Parenting from Within the Juvenile Justice System
Ann M. Nurse
The Distributional
Aspects of Social Security and Social Security Reform
Martin B. Feldstein & Jeffrey B. Liebman
Prostitution Policy: Revolutionizing Practice through a Gendered Perspective
Lenore Kuo
Practicing Sociology: Selected Fields
Robert A. Dentler
Strangers and Kin: The AmericanWay of Adoption
Barbara Melosh