Checklist Review Form Checklists Homepage
Alternate formats: Word form (download for electronic completion) Word document (download for hardcopy completion)     Checklist Number: Checklist Title: Reviewer's name:     1. Relevance to the Web Site's Purpose Relevant Tangentially Relevant Not Relevant (if selected, no other ratings required)   2. Analysis of Checklist Quality Importance of the topic Excellent Good Adequate Problematic Unacceptable Potential utility for evaluation practice Excellent Good Adequate Problematic Unacceptable Completeness/coverage of points Excellent Good Adequate Problematic Unacceptable Relevance of all points Excellent Good Adequate Problematic Unacceptable Clarity of points Excellent Good Adequate Problematic Unacceptable Organization/layout Excellent Good Adequate Problematic Unacceptable User-friendliness Excellent Good Adequate Problematic Unacceptable     3. Overall Recommendation Accept--an important contribution. Needs only minor revisions Request Revision--could be a good contribution if suitably revised. Request Extensive Revsion--a long shot, but may have potential. Reject--inappropriate, too specialized, or poor quality.     Your written comments are the most important part of your review! Please take time to fill out the comment sections that follow, especially if your recommendation is to reject or request revision of the checklist.   4. Comments for Author   5. Comments for Editor